Here's the recipe:
MAC Dsquared² Greasepaint Stick in B
MAC Trend F/W '09 Eye Shadow Compact in Tone: Grey (I used the bottom two shadows)
Hourglass Cosmetics Superficial Mascara in Carbon
* The shadow did crease after about 6 hours, so next time I'll prime my lids with Urban Decay Eyeshadow Primer Potion.